Welcome, foolish mortals, to Foolish Morsels, where sugar, butter, and a touch of enchantment come together to create delightfully delicious custom cookies. We conjure each sweet treat with care, creativity, and just enough whimsy to make every order a little magical. Whether you’re celebrating a grand occasion or simply indulging in something charmingly wicked, you’ve arrived at the perfect place.

Our Favorite Sets

Need to conjure up some inspiration? Just ask! We have done hundreds of sets and can create the set of your dreams!

Where to Buy

Currently, you can enjoy our cookies in two different ways:
– Stop by 28 Marketplace in downtown West Milton, OH, to pick up our seasonal offerings before they disappear.
– Place a Custom Order for your next event. Fill out our Custom Order Request!